Being accused of murder is one of the most serious and distressing experiences anyone can face. The gravity of the allegation, the potential consequences, and the emotional impact can be overwhelming. You may be unsure of what the law requires, what sentence could be imposed, and whether there is any possibility of receiving a suspended sentence rather than going to prison. This article provides a clear explanation of the offence of murder, how sentencing works in England and Wales, whether a suspended sentence is ever possible, and what steps you can take to improve your position at court.
Murder is a common law offence, and its definition has remained consistent for centuries. A person commits murder if they unlawfully kill another human being with intent to kill or intent to cause grievous bodily harm. The act must be unlawful, meaning it is not justified by self-defence or other lawful excuse. The mental element – known as “malice aforethought” – does not require premeditation – it simply requires the intention to cause death or really serious injury.
Murder can occur in a variety of circumstances. Some cases involve planned attacks, while others arise from sudden violence or heated disputes. Murder may result from the use of weapons, repeated blows, deliberate targeting, or even a single punch if the intent to cause serious harm is established. It may also occur where someone’s actions are so dangerous that they must have intended serious harm.
Examples include stabbing or shooting someone with lethal force, inflicting repeated blows to vital areas, striking someone with a vehicle intending to cause serious harm, or delivering an attack that clearly demonstrates an intention to cause grievous bodily harm.
The intention element distinguishes murder from manslaughter. Manslaughter applies where there is no intent to kill or cause serious harm, such as in cases of negligence, loss of control, diminished responsibility, or unlawful act manslaughter. Murder, by contrast, requires proof of intent to kill or seriously harm.
Murder carries a mandatory sentence of life imprisonment. This means that every adult convicted of murder must receive a life sentence. The court then sets a “minimum term” that must be served before the defendant may be considered for release by the Parole Board.
The minimum term depends on the seriousness of the offence. The Sentencing Council issues guidelines for murder that set starting points for the minimum term.
These are starting points only. Aggravating and mitigating factors adjust the final minimum term. Aggravating factors include targeting vulnerable victims, sustained attacks, planning, sadistic behaviour, or killings related to criminal activity. Mitigating factors include lack of premeditation, mental health issues, provocation, attempts to assist the victim, or genuine remorse.
The minimum term does not represent the total length of time a person will spend on a life sentence. If released after serving the minimum term, the individual remains on licence for the rest of their life.
A suspended sentence is a custodial sentence that the court imposes but suspends for a set period. It allows the defendant to remain in the community under strict conditions. A suspended sentence can only be imposed where the custodial term is two years or less. Conditions attached to a suspended sentence can include unpaid work, rehabilitation activity requirements, curfews, exclusion zones, treatment programmes, or supervision by probation.
If the defendant complies with the conditions and commits no new offences during the suspension period, the custodial sentence is not activated. If they breach the conditions or commit further offences, the court will usually activate the suspended sentence and require the defendant to serve it in custody.
Suspended sentences are used for offences where custody is appropriate, but the court believes the defendant can safely be managed in the community.
No. A suspended sentence for murder is legally impossible. There are several reasons for this.
No exceptions exist in statute or case law allowing murder to be punished with a suspended sentence.
Because the life sentence is mandatory, the court has no power to suspend the sentence even if extraordinary mitigating circumstances exist. In cases involving diminished responsibility or loss of control, the charge may be reduced to manslaughter, but this requires evidence meeting specific legal criteria. Murder itself cannot receive a suspended sentence under any circumstances.
While a suspended sentence is not possible, courts still assess a wide range of factors when determining the appropriate minimum term.
A prison sentence is always imposed for murder because the law requires it. The mandatory life sentence applies regardless of the circumstances. There is no scenario in which murder does not cross the custody threshold.
Even the least serious murders under the guideline still attract a life sentence with a substantial minimum term. The lowest starting point for an adult is currently 15 years. This applies in cases without significant planning, where the weapon was not brought to the scene, and where there are no major aggravating features.
More serious murders attract higher starting points, such as 25 or 30 years, depending on factors such as intent, weapon use, vulnerability of the victim, or connection to criminal activity.
In the most extreme cases, a whole life order may be imposed, meaning the defendant will never be released from prison.
Although a suspended sentence is not possible, there are steps you can take to influence the length of your minimum term and strengthen your overall position.
Facing a murder allegation is devastating and life-changing. The legal process is complex, the stakes are high, and expert representation is essential. At Stuart Miller Solicitors, we have extensive experience defending clients in murder cases and understand the immense pressure you and your family may be under. We are committed to fighting your corner and ensuring your rights are protected at every stage. Get in touch today for confidential advice tailored to your situation.
Responsive
A legal expert will consult you within 24 hours of making an enquiry.
Empathetic
We will always treat you with trust, understanding and respect.
Specialised
Your case will be handled by an expert who specialises in your type of offence.
Proactive
We will take early action to end proceedings as soon as it is practically and legally possible to do so.
Engaged
You will be kept updated on your case at all times. We will provide a named contact available to answer your questions.
Caring
We understand this is a difficult and stressful time for you and your family. Our team will support you every step of the way.
Tenacious
We will never give up on your case. We fight tirelessly to get you the best possible outcome.